Many nonprofit board members volunteer because they believe in the organization’s mission — not because they have experience overseeing finances, managing employees or complying with regulations.
Even well-intentioned decisions can lead to lawsuits alleging mismanagement, negligence or breaches of fiduciary duty. Directors and officers liability insurance helps protect these individuals and the nonprofit from the potentially substantial costs of defending such claims.
What D&O insurance covers
D&O insurance addresses allegations of wrongful acts committed while managing an organization. Coverage may provide:
- Individual protection: Pays covered legal defense costs, settlements and judgments against directors and officers when the nonprofit cannot or will not indemnify them, helping protect their personal assets.
- Reimbursement for legal expenses: Reimburses the organization when it pays covered legal expenses, settlements or judgments on behalf of its directors and officers.
- Protection for the organization: Covers certain claims brought directly against the nonprofit for alleged management-related wrongful acts.
D&O insurance may cover defense costs even when allegations are unfounded or claims are ultimately dismissed. Directors and officers do not have to be found liable for coverage to apply.
How board members can be held personally liable
Nonprofit directors have fiduciary duties that require them to act in the organization’s best interests, exercise reasonable care and oversee its financial affairs. However, if they are accused of failing to fulfill these responsibilities, they may face lawsuits brought by employees, donors, members, regulators and other parties.
Consider a nonprofit board that approves a major expenditure without adequately reviewing the organization’s finances. If the decision results in substantial losses, board members could face allegations that they failed to exercise appropriate oversight.
Similarly, board members who ignore complaints about an executive director’s conduct could face claims that they neglected their responsibilities.
Even when allegations are unfounded, defending a lawsuit can cost tens of thousands of dollars. Without appropriate insurance or indemnification, individual directors may have to pay their own legal expenses.
Common sources of D&O claims
Nonprofit organizations face several types of management liability exposures:
- Financial mismanagement: Allegations that directors mismanaged donations, investments, endowments or other organizational assets.
- Employment disputes: Claims involving wrongful termination, discrimination, harassment or retaliation. These exposures may require employment practices liability coverage, which is sometimes included in D&O policies.
- Conflicts of interest: Accusations that board members benefited personally from organizational transactions or failed to disclose financial relationships.
- Regulatory violations: Allegations involving improper financial reporting, failure to comply with nonprofit regulations or misuse of restricted charitable funds.
- Donor and member disputes: Claims that contributions were not used as promised or that leadership violated organizational bylaws.
- Governance failures: Allegations that directors failed to supervise management, follow established procedures or adequately oversee the organization’s activities.
Volunteer status does not eliminate liability
Some nonprofit directors mistakenly believe that serving without compensation shields them from personal liability.
The federal Volunteer Protection Act provides certain protections for qualifying volunteers acting within the scope of their responsibilities. However, those protections have limitations, including exceptions for gross negligence and willful misconduct. Statelaws also vary.
Statutory immunity does not necessarily eliminate the expense of defending a lawsuit.
Smaller nonprofits can be particularly vulnerable because they often lack dedicated legal counsel, human resources personnel and formal governance procedures.
Choosing appropriate protection
When purchasing D&O insurance, nonprofits should review policy limits, exclusions, employment practices coverage and whether former directors and officers remain protected for qualifying claims.
D&O policies generally exclude deliberate fraud and criminal misconduct. They also typically exclude bodily injury and property damage, which are generally addressed by other liability policies.
It’s important to understand that insurance is not a substitute for sound governance practices, including training board members, maintaining accurate financial records, documenting decisions and establishing conflict-of-interest policies.
